@Aligarciaherrer on X
China's AI has users but no profits, so sell
Chinese AI stocks fell because the companies can't turn popular models into profits, not because AI prices were a bubble.
Result
If held over the last 3 months (Aug 15, 2026 – Nov 14, 2026): +27.6%. Over the same days: S&P 500 −2.2%, Chip stocks −14.6%.
What it holds
- Model makers that can't charge, 32% of the money, +60.7% over 3 months: against ZHIPU (Zhipu AI), against MINIMAX (MiniMax). Free and cheap models bring users but not enough money, so pure AI labs suffer most.
- Big platforms funding the AI race, 20% of the money, +17.4% over 3 months: against BABA (Alibaba), against TCNT (Tencent). Giant tech firms spend a lot on AI, and if the spending doesn't pay off, their stocks suffer.
- Chips and robots: the new growth engines, 28% of the money, −2.1% over 3 months: against CAMBRICON (Cambricon), against CXMT, against UNITREE (Unitree). If AI can't make money, the chip and robot hopes built on top of it look weaker too.
- Cash, 20%.
The plan behind it
The speaker says Chinese AI firms never had sky-high prices. Their real problem is that people use their models but don't pay enough. Price cuts and tough competition (called involution) make it worse. So the portfolio bets against Chinese AI companies that have the hardest time making money. The biggest short is on the pure model makers. Smaller shorts cover the big platforms, chip makers and robot makers, which rely on AI becoming a new growth engine. Some cash stays on the side because these stocks could bounce on good news.
I joined Francesca Ghiretti on Geoeconomic Competition to discuss the recent sell-off in Chinese AI stocks. My view is that this is less about an AI bubble bursting and more about China’s involution problem. Unlike in the US, Chinese AI companies never reached such high valuations. Many went public relatively early as traditional funding sources, including local governments, state-owned enterprises and foreign investors, became increasingly constrained. The deeper issue is profitability. Chinese open-weight models have gained traction, but usage has not translated into sufficient revenues. Fierce competition and falling prices for closed models are making monetisation even harder. Uncertainty over China’s proposed technology export controls has added to market concerns. The problem is not China’s ability to innovate, but its ability to turn innovation into sustainable profits. And this raises a broader question: can AI, robotics and biotech really become China’s new growth engines when the economy continues to face structural challenges? Thanks to Francesca for the interesting discussion! Listen to the full podcast: https://t.co/UwISCjcrmC #China #AI #Involution
What would prove it wrong: Sell out if Chinese AI firms show fast, steady revenue growth and profits instead of falling prices.
FAQ
How do I bet that Chinese AI stocks fell because the companies can't turn popular models into profits, not because AI prices were a bubble?
This tested idea bets against ZHIPU (Zhipu AI), MINIMAX (MiniMax), BABA (Alibaba), TCNT (Tencent), CAMBRICON (Cambricon), CXMT and UNITREE (Unitree), with 20% in cash. Make a copy to run it on practice money first, at real prices.
What would prove it wrong?
Sell out if Chinese AI firms show fast, steady revenue growth and profits instead of falling prices.
Can I make one from my own idea?
Yes. Write what you believe in plain words at https://f.xyz/create. fxyz asks a couple of questions, builds the portfolio and shows how it would have done over the last 3 months.
Can I turn a post on X into a theory?
Yes. Reply to the post and tag @fxyzai. It tests the view in the post and replies with the 3-month result and a link.
What can it trade?
Stocks (Tesla, Apple, Nvidia), crypto (Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana), pre-IPO companies (OpenAI, Anthropic), indices (Nasdaq 100, S&P 500), commodities (gold, silver, oil, copper) and currencies (EUR/USD, USD/JPY). One theory can mix them, and bet for or against any of them.
How does it react to news?
On each check it reads the last two days of news on its biggest holdings and says whether the idea still holds. It can make one small change at a time: trim or drop one holding by up to 5 points. On autopilot the change waits 10 minutes so the owner can skip it; otherwise it asks first.
How do I run it with real money?
For real money, tap Make it mine, open your copy and choose Use real money, with an exchange connected: Hyperliquid, Lighter, Lighter (Robinhood), Backpack, Pacifica or Binance. The money stays in your own account there. fxyz can place trades, but it can never withdraw.
Can the AI get it wrong?
Yes. fxyz's AI turns the idea into holdings, and it can get that wrong: add a coin or stock that doesn't fit, or miss one that does. Check the holdings before you put money in. In your own copy, ask its chat to add or drop any of them.
What do the 3-month numbers mean?
What $100 would have done holding this mix over the last 3 months, at real prices. It is a what-if, not a record: past or simulated results are no promise of future ones, and nothing here is investment advice.